[rawfeeding] Re: How risky is raw, farm-raised Tilapia from China?

Okay, single food source, sure, I'll try it.

But what about the orig question about raw tilapia from China? :) I'd
just like to know if it is an option. Thanks. :)

Kristin K

--- In rawfeeding@yahoogroups.com, "cmhausrath" <cmhausrath@...> wrote:
>
> "Kristin Knippenberg" <kknippenberg@> wrote:
>
> > I went to a holistic vet this spring. She
> > suggested that it's probably somewhat environmental, but probably
> also
> > a bit of a food allergy, and that for dogs, meats are a common
> > allergen. ANYWAY, she suggested a real, honest-to-god elimination
> diet
> > of just fish and vegetables,
>
>
> Your vet may be well-meaning, but well-educated about diet, it seems
> she's not. The food you've switched to, this Halshan fish whatever,
> contains:
>
> Pollock Fish
> Carrots
> Broccoli
> Zucchini Squash
> Peas
>
> So if your dog is, say, sensitive to sugars (carrots), or to legumes
> (peas), you're still feeding those. A REAL elimination diet would
> contain ONE and only one food source.
>
> And the idea that meat allergies are "common" in dogs -- that a
> species would frequently be allergic to the food it has evolved to
> eat -- is just preposterous. Dogs may often have trouble with COOKED
> meats, but that's a whole other thing. If you're feeding raw, you
> don't need to worry about cooked meats anyway.
>
> If it seems that I'm being overly hard on your vet, I apologize, but
> it definitely seems that she's led you astray. Since it seems that
> you've been feeding pre-made foods with unnecessary vegetables all
> along, that would be the FIRST thing I would eliminate. Why continue
> to feed something that may aggravate your dog, and that he clearly
> doesn't need, while eliminating perfectly good foods in a wild goose
> chase?
>
>
> > SO. He's currently on Halshan raw fish and veggies (I struggle to do
> > food prep, barely even for myself), but I am concerned he isn't
> > getting bone or organs with the Halshan fish.
>
>
> I too would not be comfortable feeding this food. If you're willing
> to contradict the advice of this "holistic" vet, I would recommend
> that you choose another single protein source and feed ONLY that for
> at least a month. It seems that you've not fed turkey, and that's
> readily available without great expense. I know you think you can't
> afford the food prep time, but there IS basically no food prep time.
> Just buy whole turkeys or turkey breasts, whack them up, and feed.
> No veggies, no mixing, no blending, no complicated anything.
>
> Please read thru the pages on
> http://rawfed.com/ (especially the "myths") and
> http://www.rawlearning.com/ and check out
> http://www.rawfeddogs.net/Recipes
>
> And please ask whatever questions you have -- we're here to help!
>
> -- sandy (cranky with "holistic" vets after a similar experience) &
> griffin (basically never cranky, but he can't type)
>

All information on this list represents personal opinion only. By staying on this list, you agree to never hold anyone from this list or associated with this list liable for any information posted through this list. You agree to take personal responsibility for your learning, and for personal responsibility for what you feed yourself, your family, and your dogs, cats, ferrets, or any other animal that lives under your care. If you don't agree, please unsubscribe immediately.
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/rawfeeding/

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/rawfeeding/join

(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
mailto:rawfeeding-digest@yahoogroups.com
mailto:rawfeeding-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
rawfeeding-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/